Most baseball fans recall September 28, 2011 as one of the best, single nights in the history of the sport, and who could blame them. It was truly an extraordinary set of circumstances involving so many teams and scenarios with an ending that even the best writers in Hollywood couldn’t have scripted.
As September approached, with only one wild-card spot available in each league at the time, the playoff spots seemed set in stone without much hope of late season drama to look forward to. The American League division leaders were the Red Sox, Tigers and Rangers and the Yankees holding down the Wild Card spot, but only 1.5 games behind the Sox for the A.L. East. The Tigers and Rangers held secure leads over their second place rivals and the nearest wild card contender to the Yankees was 7.5 games back (Tampa). The National League was eerily similar. The Phillies, Brewers and Diamondbacks all holding command leads in their respective divisions and the Braves had a 9 game lead over the Cardinals for the Wild Card spot. The only drama seemed to be between the Red Sox and Yankees deciding the East and the Wild Card.
As the month played out, the N.L. leaders continued their winning ways without working up a sweat on their way to division titles, but the Braves started to falter and the Cardinals caught fire. The Red Birds seemed to be winning in magical ways while the Braves looked like a second division club and jinxed with every game they played. That stretch included a Cardinals sweep of the Braves in early September and then the Braves losing five of six in the last week to set up a final game against the Phillies while the Cardinals were in Houston.
The American League almost mirrored the N.L. as the Tigers and Rangers also ruled their divisions without much of a challenge, but the A.L. East was getting interesting. The Yankees and Red Sox had flip flopped and were clearly heading in opposite directions, but still not much fear of the Devil Rays (yes I called them Devil Rays, get over it!) catching the Sox for the wild card. Well this is baseball and these are the Red Sox, and never say never as they lost six of seven to the Devil Rays over a nine day span to suddenly make things interesting and put Tampa right in the middle of the playoff chase. The Red Sox would finish the last two weeks of the season with a 4-9 record including losing four of six to the last-place Orioles heading into the final game in Baltimore.
September 28 brought with it the ultimate stage for baseball fans around the country, even those who didn’t have a dog in the fight. The Cardinals and Braves were tied for the N.L. Wild Card and the Red Sox and Devil Rays were tied for the A.L. Wild Card. Pop the popcorn and line up the T.V. sets next to each other because this was baseball nirvana with the following line up of games that had playoff implications:
Cardinals @ Astros – an afternoon game giving the ‘Birds an advantage should they win
Phillies @ Braves – Phillies had nothing to play for and Braves everything to play for
Red Sox @ Orioles – Win and hope for some help from the Yankees to win the Wild Card
Yankees @ Devil Rays – Rays need a win to stay even and hope for a one game playoff
The last three games all started around the same time adding to the excitement, and each one trying to top the other on the drama-meter. The Cards won easily in Houston to put the weight of the world on the Braves while they relaxed in unison in the visiting clubhouse of Minute Maid Park awaiting their travel plans
· The Braves would take a one run lead in to the ninth and their all-star closer on the mound with hopes of forcing a one-game playoff with the Cardinals to determine the wild card winner.
· The Red Sox would take a one run lead in to the ninth and their all-star closer on the mound and also a 77-0 record when leading after eight innings. A win puts them in the temporary lead to win the wild card and at a minimum forces a one game playoff for the wild card spot
· The Devils Rays, trailed the Yankees 7-0 in the eighth inning…..then scored six in the eighth to trail by one also heading into the ninth inning
Then it really got interesting….
Kimbrel, for the Braves, blows the save and the Phillies tie the game. The Devil Rays were down to their last out, down a run to the Yankees when Dan Johnson goes yard to tie the game. Dan Johnson, who had not had a major league hit since April, ties the freaking game. The Braves/Phillies were headed to extra innings as were the Yankees and Devil Rays. The Sox/Orioles game seemed to drag on despite the low scoring affair while the other two games of importance moved along much more quickly.
As those two games moved on into the twelfth innings, the Sox blew a chance for some insurance runs in the top of the ninth by not capitalizing on a bases loaded, one out situation. Still 3-2, the Sox headed to the bottom of the ninth. Papelbon cruised through the first two batters and needed just more one out to put it away. At the same time the Yankees had runners on first and third with no outs threatening to go ahead in the twelfth. I remember looking at the clock and thinking “The Red Sox might actually pull this out and get a reprieve from the baseball gods.” Comebacks in 2004, 2007 and almost again in 2008 gave me hope that the baseball gods were done punishing the Sox and their fans. It was exactly midnight.
This is what happened in the next five minutes. The Orioles Chris Davis Doubled, Nolan Reimold Doubled (tie game now), Robert Andino singled, Orioles win. Just as quickly as that…no joking. Robert Andino now occupied a spot reserved previously for the likes of Bucky Dent, Aaron Boone and Ray Knight. Robert Andino had three huge hits in the last eight games, all late in the game, all against the Red Sox. I then switched the channel to root for the Yankees (yes those words came out of my mouth) and hoping they had scored to gain the lead. Within one minute of realizing it was still tied, Evan Longoria homered to win the game. It was 12:05 a.m. Rays in, Sox out, go outside to throw up, back inside to find the nearest adult beverage and back outside to listen to the silence of the night.
Minutes later the Braves lost in thirteen innings to at least share the debacle that was the great collapse of 2011, but at that point, it really didn’t matter. As it turned out, Chicken and Beer in my man cave might have been a more appropriate post-game meal following the reports involving certain Red Sox players and their retreat to the clubhouse during games to enjoy KFC and Sam Adams during the September Swoon that produced a 7-20 record.
Red Sox fans might finally be able to look at September 28, 2011 in the same light as other fans, but it took a full 730 days to let that bitterness go and move forward. That seems like a short time considering I was bitter about Bucky Dent for 26 years, give or take a few days. This year’s team, no matter what the outcome is, helped erase that bitterness of 2011 and 2012, with its clutch hitting, high five city and of course the beards and the bonding. Boston Strong and go Sox!
And that's what it is in the world of the Sports Grapevine .......